First of all, have you played it?
Where and when did you play it?
Were you scared at some point?
Did you complete it or exited the first time you saw The Shadow?
Is it the most scariest game you have ever played? If not what was worse?
I did and do play it, it was dark in my room and the clock was about 2 at night. I was freaked out but I continued playing it even after i saw The Shadow. So I enjoyed the game, and it is the most scary horror game out there, and yes I have to agree that Death Space 2 is awful aswell, but you cant fucking compare those games, Death Space 2 is fast phased REALLY FAST PHASED, and you have a fucking gun, you can fight back! In Amnesia you have to run and hide while solving puzzles and don't get killed, you also have panic attacks and shit like that, witch makes it even worse, but Amnesia over all is the scariest game that have ever been made, so if you haven't tried it yet make sure to try it.